IRB "Precedent"

“Haven’t we had a case like this before?” We know IRBs often rely on institutional memory when reviewing research applications. But what if we formalized that approach through decision summaries detailing the relevant issue, decision outcome, and rationale in a way that could inform future decisions? This can improve consistency and efficiency, two critical goals for any IRB. It can also help clarify challenging research ethics standards through case-based reasoning. For example, what does it mean for research risks to be minimized, for research to be impracticable if consent is required, for offers of payment to be acceptable? Each of these questions and many others can be clarified through analyzing the facts of specific cases and then determining how the facts of a new case compare and contrast. This is precisely how judges develop the “common law."


Several AEREO members have been collaborating to develop a system of IRB “precedent” and test it at their sites. To clarify that these precedents are not formally binding but rather instructive, we often refer instead to “decision summaries” and “decision summary banks.” If you’d like to learn more about this work and possibly get involved, please request our decision summary template and FAQs by filling out this brief form. This is a free resource, we simply ask for your name, institution, and email address to help gauge interest. We hope you will join us in this effort!


You can also learn more by reviewing this brief slide deck, “IRB Precedent in Theory and Practice,” as well as this manuscript explaining why we think IRB precedent is important (and documenting an earlier approach). In addition to bringing additional sites on board, we’re working to consider barriers and facilitators to adopting a system of IRB precedent, to determine how AI might be used to help support efforts to document IRB decisions and identify relevant prior decisions, and to facilitate sharing IRB decision summaries with investigators and across sites to improve their utility.


Please contact Holly Fernandez Lynch, AEREO Co-Chair, for more information: lynchhf@pennmedicine.upenn.edu.